| CRITIQUE |
| Guided
By Voices - Hold On Hope EP, (TVT Records) published: April 30, 2000, tidalwavemag.com |
Robert
Pollard and his Guided by Voices collect some outtakes from the Do the
Collapse (their brilliant indie power pop Who rock record from 1999) onto
the EP format. These tracks offer a glimpse into Pollard’s backlog
of songs that didn’t make the full length; for whatever reason.
It isn’t a surprise, because in the past a GbV record contains more
than twenty songs (from 30 second snippets to typical two and a half minute
songs). Regardless of what you think of “the EP” format, this
is worth your eight bucks.
The nine song Hold On Hope EP is for the fan. From the opening power pop of “Underground Initiations” to the instrumental “Do the Collapse”, Pollard gives the diehard GbV fan another dose, high kicks and beer stains included in the purchase price. There are two types of songs here: indie arena rock (ala DTC) and classic GbV tracks. “Underground Initiations” is a perfect fit for the indie arena rock/power pop that permeates the full-length that Pollard has been recording as of late. The opening ringing guitar riff is familiar territory that is immediately rocked by crunchy guitars and Pollard’s cigarette stained vocals. It’s almost a shame that the song didn’t make Do the Collapse. “Idiot Princess” is another classic rocker with distorto vocals. “Avalanche Aminos” is marked by a psychotic guitar riff with big drums and herky jerky rhythms until the chorus drives hard with Pollard’s vocals soaring. Pollard gets more familiar to old school indiots on “Fly Into Ashes”, a track that is feels lo-fi (one of three songs on the EP that were not produced by Ric Ocasek). This is classic Guided by Voices. Pollard isn’t about to let up on the fifty second acoustic “Tropical Robots” where he utilizes one of favorite subject matters, robots. When he sings: “Alabama policeman, let em go on their way, don’t spoil their fun, cause when they go away, they won’t come back no more” he sings the immediately recognizable GbV melody, employing his philosophy of song economy (why add another verse/chorus? This is sufficient). Pollard plays the Beatle card on “A Crick Uphill” (think “I’m Looking Through You” from Rubber Soul). This song could have fit well on Bee Thousand or Alien Lanes. Classic. The EP closes with the magnificent single, “Hold On Hope”. Funny, end the thing with the single. While Pollard gives a healthy dose of classic GbV indie rock, and outtakes from the Do the Collapse sessions, one has to wonder about “Interest Position”, a boring emo song. Perhaps Pollard is saying, “Hell, anyone can do this shit, even an old fart like me. Now that is out of the way…” High Kick. |
|
|
|
© 2000 tidalwavemag.com |